During a class two and a half hours after recess.
6th grade student: Can I go to the nurse? My tooth fell out.
Me: What?? When, just now?
Student: No, recess.
Me: What?! Why are you just now asking to go to the nurse?
Student #2: He lost it.
Student #1: Yeah, and I just found it.
Student #1: In my sock.
At that point, I just stopped asking questions and let him go.